• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Johnnys Pizza Raleigh - Best NY-Style Pizza, Subs & More in Raleigh, NC

Johnnys Pizza Raleigh on Lead Mine Road is a standout spot delivering authentic, New York-style pizza with perfectly balanced sauce, crisp crust, and generous toppings. Locals rave about their flavorful subs, crispy wings, and fluffy garlic knots paired with a zesty marinara. The menu also offers rich pasta dishes like Penne ala Vodka and fresh antipasto salads, showcasing diverse Italian-American flavors. Friendly service adds warmth to every visit, making it feel like a neighborhood favorite rather than just another chain. For anyone seeking quality, affordability, and a true pizza experience in Raleigh, Johnny’s is a must-try that consistently impresses.

Johnnys Pizza Raleigh at a glance

  • Address 7713 Lead Mine Rd #45, Raleigh, NC 27615, United States
  • Phone +1 919-615-0450
  • Restaurant type Pizza restaurant .

Photos & Gallery

Johnnys Pizza Raleigh: Reviews & Ratings

Teresa Bishop
5

My husband is a pizza connoisseur of sorts. I also love pizza but not to the degree he does. We both agreed this is 100% the best pizza we have ever had, and we have lived in multiple states. They are always posting awesome deals too. Everything is amazing. The subs, slices, whole pizzas, appetizers. The fried breadsticks are out of this world. Highly recommend

Nick DiColandrea
5

FINALLY GOOD PIZZA IN THE SHOPPING CENTER! While a chain, I was pleasantly surprised with this place moving in after the failure of the previous joint. Finally a pizza place to complement the beer cave, ice cream shop, Mexican food and playground area. The staff is so friendly and makes it not feel like the rundown place of old. Immediately make you feel right at home. The pizza - plain cheese - is not only very good (almost NY style) but doesn’t cost you an arm and a leg. We also got a veggie calzone and it was done perfectly. Veggies weren’t watery, cheese mix was great and the crust was wonderfully crisp. We will be back often!

Aaliyah Carrington
5

Wonderful experience both times ! The pizza is phenomenal! Enough toppings, sauce, cheese all the above. The pasta was good too ! Definitely worth a try and the guys in there are so nice and sweet . Customer service was top tier

Khoi Tran
5

Had Johnny's Pizza for takeout so friends and I could enjoy good food for a Sunday night football game. Antipasto salad portion was generous and well distributed with the meats, cheese, and olives. He also accommodated dressing on the side because I didn't want the salad to get soggy before receiving. Garlic knots were fluffy and the marinara sauce was delicious with a little kick with red pepper flakes. The buffalo chicken pizza had a crispy crust and well-seasoned chicken and the house ranch was a perfect addition to every bite. Definitely looking forward to making this a consistent staple!

Jaime Allen
5

I am a self-proclaimed Pizza snob! I have seen Johnny's advertised for years, but I just was never in the area. Well, so glad now they are in my own backyard! Tried the pizza last week, then tried some wings, and Penne ala Vodka. Let me just say, it is the best pizza I have had in all my years in Raleigh! The thing about NY pizza is getting the sauce right, and Johnny's does just that!

Courtney Frank
5

We tried the buffalo chicken pizza at the Cary location which was the best we've had around here. Then when Lead Mine just opened closer to our home (still a distance) we ordered delivery twice and it's again been the best pizza and calzones we've had in a long time. My favorite is a chicken parm pizza and i can not wait to try theirs. We've designated Johnnys our go to for pizza and I can't get enough of the spinach calzone. I hope they keep delivering out towards Briar Creek

Phil Hathaway
5

Best lunch combo in Raleigh!! I mean two perfectly baked NY slices the size of your face and a drink for only $8?? Can’t beat it…service was great, food came out real quick. A significant upgrade in all aspects over “Papa’s pizza” that was previously here. Been waiting for Johnny’s to come to N Raleigh for several years now and stoked that he landed at Greystone! (second slice not pictured bc I ate it too fast before I could post!)

Elliot Salman
5

So happy a new spot opened up in Greystone Village. We met Johnny about a week before they opened - super nice guy who really cares about the product he puts out. I’m no pizza snob but the pizza here is definitely a notch above our usual go-to spots. Nice crispy undercarriage which you don’t get at most places, good crust, great flavor. Friendly staff as well. New go-to spot!

Location

  • Johnnys Pizza Raleigh
    Johnnys Pizza Raleigh
    7713 Lead Mine Rd #45, Raleigh, NC 27615, United States Hotline: +1 919-615-0450

Located on Lead Mine Road in Raleigh, Johnnys Pizza Raleigh stands out as a true gem for pizza lovers seeking authentic, flavorful pies that capture the essence of New York-style craftsmanship. From the moment you step inside, the friendly staff welcomes you with genuine warmth, creating a relaxed atmosphere that feels more like a neighborhood pizzeria than a chain. This sense of hospitality shines through in every interaction, elevating the dining experience beyond just the food.

The real star here is the pizza. Crisp, thin crusts provide the perfect foundation, boasting a balanced chewiness that holds up beautifully under generous layers of rich tomato sauce and a blend of cheeses. Reviews rave about the sauce – tangy, perfectly seasoned, and possessing that elusive NYC flavor profile—paired with just the right amount of toppings that never overwhelm. Whether you opt for a simple cheese slice or a specialty like the buffalo chicken with its well-seasoned, crispy crust, John's pizza promises consistent quality and taste.

But the offerings don’t stop there. The appetizers, especially the fried breadsticks and fluffy garlic knots accompanied by a vibrant, spicy marinara, are standout starters that complement the menu brilliantly. The antipasto salad is thoughtfully composed, balancing cured meats, cheese, and olives with a dressing served on the side to keep flavors fresh. Pasta dishes, such as the Penne ala Vodka, bring an added dimension to the menu, showcasing versatility beyond traditional pizzeria fare.

Value is another highlight. Despite the high-quality ingredients and authentic preparation, prices remain approachable, making Johnnys Pizza Raleigh a reliable spot for casual meals or special occasions alike. The frequent deals and promotions add even more appeal, encouraging both pizza aficionados and casual diners to return often.

In essence, Johnnys Pizza Raleigh delivers on every front—ambiance, service, and, most importantly, taste. It’s clear why locals and visitors alike regard it as one of the best pizza places in the area. For anyone craving a genuine slice of New York-style pizza paired with exceptional service and a welcoming vibe, this spot is not to be missed.

Business Information

  • Service options
    • Kerbside pickup
    • No-contact delivery
    • Delivery
    • Takeaway
    • Dine-in